Talk:Hogwarts AU/@comment-99.118.64.7-20140621222704/@comment-16059609-20140717230840

Jack in Hufflepuff... I suppose that could work. No worse than Gryffindor or Slytherin. Now Jack Frost in Ravenclaw, that would be trouble. Just imagine it: none of the other Ravenclaws would get ANYTHING done, Jack would be pranking them like there was no tomorrow!

Hiccup in Slytherin: Uhhhmm, NO. If Hiccup was selfish, he would have flown away with Toothless as soon as he had that saddle built. He only left when his village when they wanted him to harm another creature. I'd say that's pretty selfless. Though I don't personally put him in Hufflepuff, that makes a lot more sense than Slytherin. Besides, Slytherins aren't all selfish, they're ambitious, and Hiccup terribly reluctant to take charge as chief for a Slytherin if you ask me.

I suppose you have a point about Rapunzel's ambition, but she is also pretty selfless-- she just wants to be there for her mother (or who she thought was her mother): that's why she was planning on going back to her tower after she saw the lights. I'd say that was Hufflepuff. However the reason she left in the first place was because she couldn't resist her curiosity, which I say would be very Ravenclaw of her.

I agree with you on Merida's Slytherin attributes, but her Slytherin attributes got her in trouble. I think the sorting hat would have put her in Gryffindor to remind her to be brave, instead of selfish. That's my opinion.