Talk:Hogwarts AU/@comment-187.79.254.121-20140808151157/@comment-16059609-20140908185940

Ok I have to admit I like the second casting a lot better. Hans as Boromir actually would work really well!

I don't know about Jack as Gandalf. One one hand, it would make sense- Jack falls into the lake and dies, being revived more powerful than he was before; Gandalf falls into the pit, fights the Balrog, dies, is reserected more powerful than he was before. It would work. I don't know if the personality would fit though. It would be neat.

Gothel as female Gollum would be awesome.