Talk:Hogwarts AU/@comment-148.204.160.48-20140428201843/@comment-24853231-20140722082624

I think Durmstrang is a good choice for Dagur, because of the way that the school is taught. it is taught in a much more violent mannerism, with more focus on the bad kind of training than good.

Heather could be placed in Slytherin, but I have always thought of her as somewhat of a Ravenclaw. She exhibits many traits of a Slytherin, like cunning and resourcefullness, however she uses brains and not brawn in every situation she is thrown into. I see why people put her as a Gryffindor, but she doesnt actually exhibit many Gryffindor qualitys. Yes, she could be said to be brave for standing up to Alvin, but in all honesty, she is just trying to save her parents. She is doing it for her own gain, which is more the mindset of a Slytherin, not for anyone else. And even when she does help Hiccup in the end, she still gets something out of it.

Astrid is difficult. She can be portrayed as a Slytherin, Gryffindor, or even a Hufflepuff. To prove a point for being a Hufflepuff, she is hardworking and very loyal to her tribe, no matter the cost. Her qualities of Slytherin tie into this, as what she most exhibits of Slytherin traits is ambition. She is also quite resourceful. She is also a good candidate for Gryffindor, although I don't think this works as well for her. She is brave, but her true bravery begins to shine through when she tries to go save hiccup when he is being attacked my the Monstrus Nightmare. Right then is when it switches from being, "I'll defend my tribe" bravery to, "This is whats actually right and I need to stand up for it" bravery. Also, she isn't reckless like a Gryffindor. She keeps a cool head in sticky situations and she can tell the difference between good and bad choices even when distracted.

So all in all, I would say Dagur goes to Durmstrang, Heather is in Slytherin, possibly Ravenclaw, and Astrid would be either in Slytherin or Hufflepuff.


 * Looks up*****

Why are my reveiws always so long?